Ready to get started? Call (866) 874-8374

Historic Cayuga Lake House with 245 Feet of Lakefront


Owner Name: Michael & Ileana Hoeschele
Owner Phone: (585) 271-6706 home; (585) 703-1831 cell
MLS #R269601


Type: Historic Bedrooms: 5
Baths: 2
No. Rooms: 9
Style: Colonial
Exterior: Wood (painted 2007), Vinyl Shutters (2007), Basement Windows (2014), Pella Windows Downstairs (2014), Vinyl Siding (2015), Trim Painted (2015)
Garage: Barn
Driveway: Stone/Gravel
Basement: Full
Floors: Ceramic-some, Wood-some, Wall to Wall
Attic: Crawl Space
Kitchen/Dining: Eat-in, Formal, Pantry

Lot Information: Beach at Lakefront, Primary Road, Rural
Road, Water View from House
Waterfront: Lake/Cayuga Lake Waterfront Footage: 245 x 76

Public Remarks: Many recent updates and improvements. Make an offer!
Great single family residence or Bed and Breakfast w/ 245' nice west Cayuga Lake shore frontage. One of the best parts of the lake, pristine water, very little vegetation. Home well done with wide plank floors, stenciling, all with original 1843 look. Remodeled kitchen (2009) with new appliances. Remodeled downstairs bathroom (2013). New basement storm windows (2013). New circuit breakers/panel (2014). New Pella windows (2014). Vinyl siding with painted trim (2015). Several freshly painted rooms. Newly renovated bedroom. Fenced in side yard. Nice shale beach, deck, dock and shed across the road at lake front. Located on the west side of Cayuga Lake, just minutes from Seneca Falls (13 miles) and Ithaca (25 miles). It is close to the wineries (one is basically in our back yard) on both Cayuga and Seneca Lakes. Only 20 miles from the Del Lago Casino.
Excellent rental history. Buyer's agents welcome.

Directions: Starting from Rochester, take thruway
exit 41 to Rt. 89 south about 17 miles.


Additional Rooms: 1st floor laundry (washer and dryer included), Den/Study, Foyer/Entry Hall, Open Porch, Workshop
Interior Features: Water Treatment System, Other-see remarks
Fireplaces: Kitchen-electric heater in form of wood-burning stove, Dining Room-closed in by previous owners
Kitchen Appliances Included: Gas Oven (2007), Refrigerator, Dishwasher (2007)

Exterior Features: Barn/Out Building w/right and left sheds, Dock (2007), Deck and Shed by water, 3 Stone Patios
(north w/ white vinyl fence)
Storms : Double Pane Windows
Insulation: Wall-some, Floors-some


Heating/Cooling System: Steam
Heating Fuel: Oil
Water Heater: Electric
Sewer: Septic
Water: Well and Lake Systems


Living Room: 14 X 15
Dining Room: 14 X 15
Kitchen: 11' x 2
Upstairs Den: 6 X 8
Bedroom 1: 11 X 11
Bedroom 2: 16 X 13
Bedroom 3: 10 X 12
Bedroom 4: 12 X 9
Bedroom 5: 6 X 8
Bathroom 1: 8.25 X 9
Bathroom 2: 9.5 X 8.75
Barn: Center 2 Story: 20 X 30
Fenced in Patio: 25 X 25
Right and Left Sheds: 10 X 30

Status: active
Views: 2,398
  • Listing ID: MWM1906
  • Property type: Single Family Home
  • Year built: 1843
  • County: Seneca
  • School district: Romulus Central Schools
  • Cooling: None
  • Heating: Oil
  • Parking: Other

Property Basics

Property Type: Single Family Home | 5 bedrooms | Bathrooms: 2 full | Square Feet: 1894 | Lot Size: 1.85 acres | Status: active | Listing ID: MWM1906

Structural Details

Architecture: Farmhouse | Year Built: 1843 | Heating: Oil | Fireplace: 1 | Air Conditioning: None | Sewer: Septic | Parking: Other | Special Features: Barn Or Stable, Basement, High Efficiency Appliances, Professional Landscaping, Recently Renovated, Shed, Updated Bathroom, Updated Kitchen, Workshop, Wired Ethernet | Exterior: Vinyl, Wood | Roof: Other | Report(s) Available: Electrical Inspection, Home Inspection, Plumbing Inspection, Pest Inspection, Sewer Inspection

Utilities & Taxes

Property Taxes: 11440.00, Yearly


School District: Romulus Central Schools | Zoning: Agricultural | Topography: Field Or Meadow | Views: General Scenic, General Water View, Lakefront, Woods | Utilities: Cable, Electricity, Gas, Water

School Information

Public School
Private School
School Rating
The GreatSchools rating is a simple tool for parnets to compare schools based on test scores. It compares schools across the state.
Above Average
Below Average
Out of 10

Romulus Elementary School


Search near this school
3.4 mi
Out of 10

Romulus Middle-high School


Search near this school
3.4 mi
Data provided by
School Rating
The GreatSchools rating is a simple tool for parnets to compare schools based on test scores. It compares schools across the state.
Above Average
Below Average
Out of 10

Diamond Crossing School

Search near this school
2.6 mi
Out of 10

Cranberry Marsh School

Search near this school
2.7 mi
Data provided by

Tools for buyers

Ready to sell? We've got you covered.

List your home, reach more buyers.
Get expert advice along the way.
Save thousands on commission.

Enter Password

To access this content, please confirm your account password below.

Password is requiredPlease enter a valid password

Email sent

Check your inbox at and follow the instructions to reset your password.

Don't miss a listing.
Don't miss a listing.
Download the® app today